Publications related to F#
F# is about clarity of thinking and expression - “computational thinking made manifest” - and is loved by academics and researchers for bringing clear, concise problem solving techniques developed in academia into practice. F# is both based on academic research and acts as an inspiration for thousands of students and researchers worldwide. Many standard F# features (including active patterns and asynchronous workflows) have been described in academic literature, and many research projects build on top of F#.
To add a paper to this list, log on to GitHub, edit this page and submit a pull request.
Information-rich programming - publications related to F# type providers, a novel mechanism that integrates large-scale data into statically typed function programming language.
Asynchronous, Concurrent and Reactive programming - publications about F# asynchronous workflows, the asynchronous programming model used in F#, event-based programming and “joinads”, a research extension of F# computation expression syntax for concurrent, reactive and parallel programming patterns.
Parallel, Distributed and Cloud programming - publications related to parallel and distributed programming using F#.
Functional programming - publications about core F# language features including active patterns and intialization of mutually recursive values.
DSLs and Meta-programming - publications related to DSL and meta-programming in F#.
Units of Measure - publications related to the Units of Measure feature of F#.
Web programming - publications related to web programming with F#.
Security and Verification Research - variations of F# and their use in security and verification research.
Applications - publications and academic presentations describing applications of F#.
Don Syme et al.
MSR Technical Report
A growing trend in both the theory and practice of programming is the interaction between programming and rich information spaces. From databases to web services to the semantic web to cloud-based data, the need to integrate programming with heterogeneous, connected, richly structured, streaming and evolving information sources is ever-increasing. Most modern applications incorporate one or more external information sources as integral components.
Providing strongly typed access to these sources is a key consideration for strongly-typed programming languages, to insure low impedance mismatch in information access. At this scale, information integration strategies based on library design and code generation are manual, clumsy, and do not handle the internet-scale information sources now encountered in enterprise, web and cloud environments.
In this report we describe the design and implementation of the type provider mechanism in F# 3.0 and its applications to typed programming with web ontologies, web-services, systems management information, database mappings, data markets, content management systems, economic data and hosted scripting. Type soundness becomes relative to the soundness of the type providers and the schema change in information sources, but the role of types in information-rich programming tasks is massively expanded, especially through tooling that benefits from rich types in explorative programming.
Asynchronous, Concurrent and Reactive programming
Don Syme, Tomas Petricek, Dmitry Lomov
Proceedings of PADL 2011
We describe the asynchronous programming model in F#, and its applications to reactive, parallel and concurrent programming. The key feature combines a core language with a non-blocking modality to author lightweight asynchronous tasks, where the modality has control flow constructs that are syntactically a superset of the core language and are given an asynchronous semantic interpretation. This allows smooth transitions between synchronous and asynchronous code and eliminates callback-style treatments of inversion of control, without disturbing the foundation of CPU-intensive programming that allows F# to interoperate smoothly and compile efficiently to .NET and native code.
Tomas Petricek, Don Syme
Proceedings of ISMM 2010
The reactive programming model is largely different to what we’re used to as we don’t have full control over the application’s control flow. If we mix the declarative and imperative programming style, which is usual in the ML family of languages, the situation is even more complex. It becomes easy to introduce patterns where the usual garbage collector for objects cannot automatically dispose all components that we intuitively consider garbage.
In this paper we discuss a duality between the definitions of garbage for objects and events. We combine them into a single one, to specify the notion of garbage for reactive programming model in a mixed functional/imperative language and we present a formal algorithm for collecting garbage in this environment.
Building on top of the theoretical model, we implement a library for reactive programming that does not cause leaks when used in the mixed declarative/imperative model. The library allows us to safely combine both of the reactive programming patterns. As a result, we can take advantage of the clarity and simplicity of the declarative approach as well as the expressivity of the imperative model.
Don Syme, Gregory Neverov, James Margetson Proceedings of ICFP 2007
Pattern matching of algebraic data types (ADTs) is a standard feature in typed functional programming languages, but it is well known that it interacts poorly with abstraction. While several partial solutions to this problem have been proposed, few have been implemented or used. This paper describes an extension to the .NET language F# called active patterns, which supports pattern matching over abstract representations of generic heterogeneous data such as XML and term structures, including where these are represented via object models in other .NET languages. Our design is the first to incorporate both ad hoc pattern matching functions for partial decompositions and “views” for total decompositions, and yet remains a simple and lightweight extension. We give a description of the language extension along with numerous motivating examples. Finally we describe how this feature would interact with other reasonable and related language extensions: existential types quantified at data discrimination tags, GADTs, and monadic generalizations of pattern matching.
Proceedings of ML Workshop 2006
Mutual dependencies between objects arise frequently in programs, and programmers must typically solve this value recursion by manually filling “initialization holes” to help construct the corresponding object graphs, i.e. null values and/or explicitly mutable locations. This paper aims to augment ongoing theoretical work on value recursion with a description of a semi-safe mechanism for a generalized form of value recursion in an ML-like language, where initialization corresponds to a graph of lazy computations whose nodes are sequentially forced, requiring runtime checks for soundness during initialization in the style of Russo. Our primary contribution is to use the mechanism to develop compelling examples of how the absence of value recursion leads to real problems in the presence of abstraction boundaries, and give micro-examples that characterize how initialization graphs permit more programs to be expressed in the mutation-free fragment of ML. Finally we argue that in heterogeneous programming environments semi-safe variations on value-recursion may be appropriate for ML-like languages, because initialization effects from external libraries are difficult to characterize, document and control.
Tomas Petricek, Alan Mycroft and Don Syme
Proceedings of Haskell Symposium 2011
Sequencing of effectful computations can be neatly captured using monads and elegantly
do notation. In practice such monads often allow additional ways of
composing computations, which have to be written explicitly using combinators.
We identify joinads, an abstract notion of computation that is stronger than monads
and captures many such ad-hoc extensions. In particular, joinads are monads with three
additional operations: one of type
m a -> m b -> m (a, b) captures various forms of
parallel composition, one of type
m a -> m a -> m a that is inspired by choice and one
m a -> m (m a) that captures aliasing of computations. Algebraically, the first
two operations form a near-semiring with commutative multiplication.
docase notation that can be viewed as a monadic version of
laws make it possible to prove various syntactic equivalences of programs written using
docase that are analogous to equivalences about
case. Examples of joinads that benefit
from the notation include speculative parallelism, waiting for a combination of user
interface events, but also encoding of validation rules using the intersection of parsers.
Joinads is a general-purpose research extension of the F# computation expression syntax (also
called monadic syntax) in F# and is mainly useful for concurrent, parallal and reactive
programming. The extension adds a new piece of notation, written
match! that can be
used to compose computations using non-deterministic choice, parallel composition and aliasing.
The best way to experiment with Joinads is to visit the TryJoinads.org web site, which contains a number of tutorials that can be tested in web browser capable of running Silverlight (MacOS and Windows).
Proceedings of MSFP 2012
Monads have become a powerful tool for structuring effectful computations in functional programming, because they make the order of effects explicit. When translating pure code to a monadic version, we need to specify evaluation order explicitly. This requires us to choose between call-by-value or call-by-name style. The two translations give programs with different semantics, structure and also different types.
In this paper, we translate pure code to monadic using an additional operation
that abstracts out the evaluation strategy. The
malias operation is based on computational comonads;
we use a categorical framework to specify the laws that are required to hold about the operation.
We show two implementations of
malias for any monad that give call-by-value and
call-by-name semantics. Although we do not give call-by-need semantics for any monad, we
show how to turn any monad into an extended monad with call-by-need semantics, which partly
answers a standing open question. Moreover, using our unified translation, it is possible to
change the evaluation strategy of functional code translated to the monadic form without
changing its structure or types.
Tomas Petricek and Don Syme
Proceedings of PADL 2011
Modern challenges led to a design of a wide range of programming models for reactive, parallel and concurrent programming, but these are often difficult to encode in general purpose languages. We present an abstract type of computations called joinads together with a syntactic language extension that aims to make it easier to use joinads in modern functional languages.
Our extension generalizes pattern matching to work on abstract computations. It keeps a familiar syntax and semantics of pattern matching making it easy to reason about code, even in a non-standard programming model. We demonstrate our extension using three important programming models – a reactive model based on events; a concurrent model based on join calculus and a parallel model using futures. All three models are implemented as libraries that benefit from our syntactic extension. This makes them easier to use and also opens space for exploring new useful programming models.
DSLs and Meta-programming
Leveraging .NET meta-programming components from F#: integrated queries and interoperable heterogeneous execution
Proceedings of the 2006 workshop on ML
Language-integrated meta-programming and extensible compilation have been recurring themes of
programming languages since the invention of LISP. A recent real-world application of these
techniques is the use of small meta-programs to specify database queries, as used in the
LINQ extensions for .NET. It is important that .NET languages such as F# are able to leverage the functionality provided by LINQ and related components for heterogeneous execution, both for pragmatic reasons and as a first step toward applying more disciplined, formal approaches to these problems. This paper explores the use of a modest meta-programming extension to F# to access and leverage the functionality of LINQ and other components. We do this by demonstrating an implementation of language integrated SQL queries using the LINQ/SQLMetal libraries. We also sketch two other applications: the execution of data-parallel quoted F# programs on a GPU via the Accelerator libraries, and dynamic native-code compilation via LINQ.
Tomas Petricek and Don Syme In proceedings of PADL 2014
Many computations can be structured using abstract computation types such as monoids, monad transformers or applicative functors. Functional programmers use those abstractions directly while main-stream languages often integrate concrete instances as language features - e.g. generators in Python or asynchronous computations in C# 5.0. The question is, is there a sweet spot between convenient, hardwired language features, and an inconvenient but flexible libraries?
F# computation expressions answer this question in the affirmative. Unlike the do notation in Haskell, computation expressions are not tied to a single kind of abstraction. They support a wide range of computations, depending on what operations are available. They also provide greater syntactic flexibility leading to a more intuitive syntax, without resorting to full macro-based meta-programming.
We show that computation expressions can structure well-known computations including monoidal list comprehensions, monadic parsers, applicative formlets and asynchronous sequences based on the list monad transformer. We also present typing rules for computation expressions that are capable of capturing all these applications.
Adam Granicz Central European Functional Programming School (CEFP)
In these lecture notes we present the F# implementation of a small programming language we call Simply. We give the parser implementation using active patterns, F#’s unique feature for extensible pattern matching, which as we demonstrate provide an elegant and type-safe mechanism to embed parsers as an alternative approach to parser generators. We also build an evaluator, and extend the core Simply language with Logo-like primitives and build a graphical shell environment around it. As a warm-up, we give a rudimentary survey of some notable F# features, including sequence expressions and active patterns.
Parallel and Distributed programming
Jan Dzik, Nick Palladinos, Konstantinos Rontogiannis, Eirik Tsarpalis, Nikolaos Vathis In pre-proceedings of PLOS ‘13 Seventh Workshop on Programming Languages and Operating Systems Article No. 7
As cloud computing and big data gain prominence in today’s economic landscape, the challenge of effectively articulating complex algorithms in distributed environments becomes ever more important. In this paper we describe MBrace; a novel programming model/framework for performing large scale computation in the cloud. Based on the .NET software stack, it utilizes the power of the F# programming language. MBrace introduces a declarative style for specifying and composing parallelism patterns, in what is known as cloud workflows or a cloud monad. MBrace is also a distributed execution runtime that handles orchestration of cloud workflows in the data centre.
Konstantinos Rontogiannis Diploma Thesis, National Technical University of Athens, School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, 2015
The purpose of this diploma dissertation is on one hand the description of MBrace; a programming model for performing large scale distributed computations, and on the other hand the implementation of MBrace on the Microsoft Azure cloud computing platform.
In the era of big data and cloud computing, the need for efficient and effective orchestration of distributed computations becomes a necessity. Cloud computing providers make it easy for someone to get access to computational resources needed.
Programming large scale distributed systems is a remarkably difficult task, that requires the management and orchestration of multiple concurrent processes, software and hardware failures, scalability and elasticity.
In this diploma dissertation we describe MBrace; a programming model for large scale cloud computing. Based on the F# programming language and the .NET framework stack, MBrace provides a declarative, expressive and rich model for creating and composing distributed computations. This pattern is also known as cloud workflows, or cloud monad. Finally, we have implemented this model on top of the Microsoft Azure platform, providing MBrace.Azure: a distributed execution runtime for cloud computations.
William Mansky, Dennis Griffith, Elsa L. Gunter In pre-proceedings of GRAPHITE ‘14
Compiler optimizations, usually expressed as rewrites on program graphs, are a core part of all modern compilers. However, even production compilers have bugs, and these bugs are difficult to detect and resolve. The problem only becomes more complex when compiling parallel programs; from the choice of graph representation to the possibility of race conditions, optimization designers have a range of factors to consider that do not appear when dealing with single-threaded programs. In this paper we present PTRANS, a domain-specific language for formal specification of compiler transformations, and describe its executable semantics. The fundamental approach of PTRANS is to describe program transformations as rewrites on control flow graphs with temporal logic side conditions. The syntax of PTRANS allows cleaner, more comprehensible specification of program optimizations; its executable semantics allows these specifications to act as prototypes for the optimizations themselves, so that candidate optimizations can be tested and refined before going on to include them in a compiler. We demonstrate the use of PTRANS to state, test, and refine the specification of a redundant store elimination optimization on parallel programs.
Units of Measure
Type systems for programming languages with numeric types can be extended to support the checking of units of measure. Quantification over units then introduces a new kind of parametric polymorphism with a corresponding Reynolds-style representation independence principle: that the behaviour of programs is invariant under changes to the units used. We prove this ‘dimensional invariance’ result and describe four consequences. The first is that the type of an expression can be used to derive equations which describe its properties with respect to scaling (akin to Wadler’s ‘theorems for free’ for System F). Secondly there are certain types which are inhabited only by trivial terms. For example, we prove that a fully polymorphic square root function cannot be written using just the usual arithmetic primitives. Thirdly we exhibit interesting isomorphisms between types and for first-order types relate these to the central theorem of classical dimensional analysis. Finally we suggest that for any expression whose behaviour is dimensionally invariant there exists some equivalent expression whose type reflects this behaviour, a consequence of which would be a full abstraction result for a model of the language.
Andrew Kennedy PhD Thesis, University of Cambridge, 1995
Andrew Kennedy Lecture notes , for CEFP’09, Revised July 2010
Loic Denuziere, Adam Granicz, Anton Tayanovskyy Data Driven Functional Programming 2013 (DDFP)
Joel Bjornson, Anton Tayanovskyy, and Adam Granicz The 22nd Symposium on Implementation and Application of Functional Languages (IFL)
Security and Verification Research
The experimental FStar language is inspired by F#. Some of the publications about FStar are below.
Verifying Higher-order Programs with the Dijkstra Monad, Nikhil Swamy, Joel Weinberger, Cole Schlesinger, Juan Chen, and Benjamin Livshits, in ACM Programming Language Design and Implementation (PLDI) 2013, ACM, June 2013
Self-Certification: Bootstrapping Certified Typecheckers in FStar with Coq, Pierre-Yves Strub, Nikhil Swamy, Cedric Fournet, and Juan Chen, in In Proceedings of the ACM Symposium on Principles on Programming Languages, ACM, January 2012
Secure Distributed Programming with Value-dependent Types, Nikhil Swamy, Juan Chen, Cedric Fournet, Pierre-Yves Strub, Karthikeyan Bharagavan, and Jean Yang, in The 16th ACM SIGPLAN International Conference on Functional Programming (ICFP 2011), ACM SIGPLAN, September 2011
Verified Security for Browser Extensions, Arjun Guha, Matthew Fredrikson, Benjamin Livshits, and Nikhil Swamy, in Proceedings of the IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy (Oakland), IEEE, 22 May 2011
Mechanized soundness proofs for FStar, Pierre-Yves Strub, Cedric Fournet, and Nikhil Swamy, 1 April 2011
Secure Distributed Programming with Value-Dependent Types, Nikhil Swamy, Juan Chen, Cedric Fournet, Pierre-Yves Strub, Karthikeyan Bharagavan, and Jean Yang, no. MSR-TR-2011-37, 24 March 2011
For more applications of F#, see the Testimonials page. Below are some peer-reviewed publications or academic presentations related to applications of F#.
Phil Trelford, Commercial Users of Funnctional Programming, 2006. This talk describes how the Applied Games Group at Microsoft Research Cambridge uses F#. This group consists of seven people, and specializes in the application of statistical machine learning, especially ranking problems. The ranking systems they have developed are used by the XBox Live team to do server-side analysis of game logs, and they recently entered an internal competition to improve “click-through” prediction rates on Microsoft adCenter, a multi-million dollar industry for the company. The amount of data analysed by the tools is astounding: e.g. 3TB in one case, with programs running continuously over four weeks of training data and occupying all the physical memory on the 64-bit 16GB machines we use.
F# plays a crucial role in helping the group process this data efficiently and develop smart algorithms that extract essential features from the data and represent the information using the latest statistical technique called “factor graphs”. Our use of F# in conjunction with SQL Server 2005 is especially interesting: we use novel compilation techniques to express the primary schema in F# and then use SQL Server as a data slave.
Adam Granicz, IntelliFactory Commercial Users of Functional Programming (CUFP) 2012
With proprietary plugin-based containers like Flash or Silverlight gradually losing ground, an increasing number of web applications are beginning to seek web standards compliance, and to utilize HTML5 to deliver rich and interactive client-side functionality and end-user experience. Indeed, modern browsers continue to invest heavily in establishing standard support for various HTML5 features, making HTML5 an appropriate choice for an ever-growing crowd of web developers.
Earlier this year at IntelliFactory, we completed a pilot project missioned to create a custom, innovative, and highly interactive bioinformatics web application using F# and our WebSharper technology. This application set out to serve the bioinformatics research community, and to deliver, among others, an interactive visualization of the gene sequence of a particular bacterium, with various mutations available for further research and laboratory use. The application consumed a large amount of bio data and integrated various advanced HTML5 visualizations, such as full functional gene ontology, a KEGG orthology, and a phenotype map, making it a useful web resource for researchers and laboratory staff alike.
I will present our experience report on developing this bioinformatics application, the practices and guidelines related to client-based visualization projects we distilled while developing it, the challenges we met on the way, and how we solved these challenges. Many bioinformatics algorithms are amenable to functional programming, but as a full-blown web application with advanced visualization this project yielded a great deal of details that we hope will be useful for other attendees.
Felienne Hermans, Danny Dig
Spreadsheets are widely used in industry. It is estimated that end-user programmers outnumber regular programmers by a factor of 5. However, spreadsheets are error-prone: several reports exist of companies which have lost money because of spreadsheet errors. We assert that a contributing factor to these problems is the difficulty of consistent editing of spreadsheet formulas.
Adam Granicz, IntelliFactory, Alex Peake, Veracentra Commercial Users of Functional Programming (CUFP) 2009
We have developed MarketingPlatform™ a marketing automation solution delivered as Software as a Service with F# as the primary language. MarketingPlatform™ is a solution for marketers in direct marketing and in channel marketing who would like to gain a timely and deep understanding of what is working and what is not working in their marketing campaigns. Marketers are than facilitated in the execution and delivery of campaigns, using this insight to create relevant communications to each individual. It is divided into four tightly integrated campaign management steps of Measure, Analyze, Design and Execute.
Adam Granicz, IntelliFactory Commercial Users of Functional Programming (CUFP) 2011
Native mobile applications enjoyed tremendous success in recent years, and looking at various mobile application stores such as Apple’s App Store or Google’s Android Market reveals a staggering number of native mobile applications. As technologies to build these applications mature and the market saturates, mobile OS vendors are struggling to find ways to keep up with and secure the exponential market growth. Inhibiting factors include platform-specific development environments, programming languages, and building blocks for applications; developer-unfriendly licensing, policies and subscriptions; and controlled channels of application distribution.
These problems have given rise to many promising alternatives and technologies that aim to bridge across various mobile platforms and enable sharing some or all the code in between versions of applications for different mobile OSs. Two main directions unfolded: targeting mobile code generation from mainstream languages such as C# and Java, and embracing web applications with platform-independent UI abstractions and enhanced access to the capabilities of the underlying device. While the technologies that enabled the former are an interesting topic, we believe that the latter has implications not only for mobile applications but also for their desktop counterparts, and finding ways to utilize functional programming in the development of these web-based applications has an immense impact on mobiles and desktops alike.
At the end of the talk, I will briefly touch upon our upcoming F# in the Cloud support and how that helps to seamlessly scale into the cloud desktop and mobile web applications with immense server computation needs.
Semen Grigorev, Saint Petersburg State University, Iakov Kirilenko, Saint Petersburg State University
Central & Eastern European Software Engineering Conference in Russia (CEE-SECR ‘13) 2013
Abstract parsing is an important step of the processing of dynamically constructed statements or string-embedded languages (such as embedded or dynamic SQL). Existing LALR-based algorithms have performance issues. To increase performance we propose to use a GLR-algorithm as a base for abstract parsing and to reuse graph-structured stack and shared packed parse forest. RNGLR-algorithm modification for abstract parsing is presented.